Timeline
Dominion AccuVote System causes flipped results in Wallingford CT
The Wallingford town clerk, Barbara Thompson, said Tuesday her office discovered that no votes had been recorded in the state election reporting system from the Yalesville Elementary School, one of nine polling places in the 90th District of Cheshire and Wallingford.
Dominion glitch in Michigan’s Oakland County reversed to Republican for County Board of Commissioners
Municipal worker reportedly submitted two sets of absentee ballots twice.
Georgia’s Gwinnett County blames Dominion Voting Systems for day-long delay reporting results
Gwinnett County, Georgia, an Atlanta suburb, has faced a day-long delay in reporting a crucial batch of votes due to a technical problem as the presidential race in the state hangs in the balance.
Dominion Glitch In Michigan’s Antrim County Tallied 6,000 Republican Votes As Democrat
A short investigation revealed that 47 counties in Michigan may have also suffered from a similar glitch with the same software.
Fulton County, GA shows 20,000 vote surge for Biden overnight
In the early hours of Nov. 5, a surge of some 20,000 mail-in votes suddenly appeared for Joe Biden, while approximately 1,000 votes for President Trump mysteriously disappeared from his own totals in the critical swing state, where Biden holds a razor-thin lead.
Dominion AccuVote glitch causes delay of 16,000 ballots in Londonderry, NH
Polls closed at 8 p.m. at Londonderry High School, and an estimated 16,000 ballots, including mail-in ballots, were sealed and sent off-site to the town vault by the time officials realized one of four ballot machines was not supplying the ticker tape of results.
Dominion AccuVote scanners fail to tally votes in Monadnock NH
City Clerk Patricia Little explained that a volunteer feeding absentee ballots into the AccuVote machine noticed an automated vote tally on the machine had not been changing with each new ballot. Ward 5 officials notified Little of the potential issue, estimating that the vote count was off by about 100 votes.
Dominion Systems ‘typo’ adds 138,339 to Biden in Michigan overnight
It turns out, the vote dump was the result of an alleged typo, an extra zero that had been tacked onto Biden’s vote total in Shiawassee County, Michigan. It seems the error was discovered only because Twitter users noted how insane and suspicious the vote totals looked.
Dominion Systems in Georgia’s Spalding and Morgan County fails on election day
“All I can tell you is Dominion – the company that installed the voting machines – did an update overnight and caused a glitch in the system, and therefore the machines were not working”
Logan Lamb signs affidavit attesting to GA compromised Dominion election server
Logan Lamb, a security expert for the plaintiffs, said in an affidavit filed in Atlanta federal court on that he found evidence suggesting the server was compromised in December 2014. He also testified that election related files were delated on March 2, prior to the FBI creating an image.
Microsoft releases ElectionGuard for secure voting
All major manufacturers of voting systems in the United States are working with us to explore ways to incorporate ElectionGuard into their systems.
Georgia Picks Dominion Voting System for upcoming elections
Dominion Voting Systems won the nearly $107 million contract to provide all 159 Georgia counties with electronic touch screens that produce a paper copy of the ballot. The lowest bid against two other competitors, ES&S and Smartmatic.
Texas Certifies Hybrid Voting from Hart InterCivic
The Secretary of State’s office this week certified the latest release of Hart InterCivic’s Verity® Voting system.
Missouri Certifies Hart InterCivic’s New Voting Technology
The Secretary of State and Election Division last week certified the Verity® Voting system from longtime election solution provider Hart InterCivic. Verity, already in use in counties across the U.S., is available immediately in Missouri.
Dominion Fails Certification in Texas
Pursuant to my appointment by the Texas Secretary of State as a voting systems examiner under TEXAS ELECTION CODE § 122.035, please allow this letter to serve as my report concerning the above referenced examination. I, along with the other statutory examiners and staff from the Secretary of State’s office, examined the Democracy Suite 5.5 voting system presented by Dominion Voting Systems (“Democracy 5.5 System”) on January 16 and 17, 2019, at the offices of Elections Division of the Texas Secretary of State in Austin, Texas.
Board of Elections head resigns from ES&S
The head of the city’s Board of Elections Michael Ryan, a native Staten Islander, abruptly resigned from his post on the advisory board of the maker of New York City’s voting machines, Election Systems and Software (ES&S), earlier this week. His resignation came after a NY1 report found that ES&S had flown Ryan around the country to destinations like Las Vegas putting him up in hotels and buying him dinners. Ryan reportedly did not disclose several ES&S paid trips in his annual disclosure forms with the city’s conflict of interest board.
PA Secretary of State Certifies Dominion Voter Systems
Upon the request of Dominion Voting Systems Inc. (Dominion), the Department of State’s Bureau of Commissions, Elections and Legislation (Department) scheduled an examination for October 15, 2018 of the Democracy Suite 5.5 voting system.
ES&S irregularities in Georgia’s November election for lieutenant governor
More than 150,000 voters inexplicably did not cast a vote for lieutenant governor. A state judge dismissed the suit on grounds that the complaints were limited to specific precincts, and any missing votes in those precincts would not be enough to alter the outcome of the race.
Hart InterCivic blames Texas voter problems on user error, flipped votes
Some voters have said their straight-ticket ballots have switched to candidates in the opposite party, but the company that makes the machines said they don’t do that and have been used in the last nine election cycles without any problems.
Trump Signs Executive Order on Imposing Certain Sanctions in the Event of Foreign Interference in a United States Election
(i) the extent to which any foreign interference that targeted election infrastructure materially affected the security or integrity of that infrastructure, the tabulation of votes, or the timely transmission of election results; and (ii) if any foreign interference involved activities targeting the infrastructure of, or pertaining to, a political organization, campaign, or candidate, the extent to which such activities materially affected the security or integrity of that infrastructure, including by unauthorized access to, disclosure or threatened disclosure of, or alteration or falsification of, information or data.
Controversy surrounds Louisana selection of Dominion
Hart said it offered a less-expensive proposal that doesn’t appear in the scoring documents, even though it was demonstrated to the selection committee. Election Systems and Software, the losing vendor that filed the official protest, also said it offered alternative proposals that were millions of dollars cheaper, but weren’t scored in the bid review.
Dominion Voting Systems Acquired by its Management Team and Staple Street Capital
Dominion Voting CEO and President John Poulos said, “Our senior management team is extremely pleased to partner with Staple Street Capital, which has a proven track record of successfully investing in growing mid-size businesses. Given the opportunities on our horizon, this is the ideal time for us to add financial resources and an experienced strategic partner to help us meet market demand, better serve customers and invest in evolving security initiatives.”
Venezuelan government alters at least one million votes using Smartmatic
The Venezuelan government reported false turnout figures for its contentious election over the weekend, announcing a tally that had been altered by at least one million votes, a software company involved in setting up voting systems for the country said on Wednesday. “We know, without any doubt, that the turnout of the recent election for a National Constituent Assembly was manipulated,” the company, Smartmatic, said in a statement.
Georgia’s Dominion election server wiped after charges filed for fraud
The lawsuit, filed July 3 by a diverse group of election reform advocates, aims to force Georgia to retire its antiquated and heavily criticized election technology. The server in question, which served as a statewide staging location for key election-related data, made national headlines in June after a security expert disclosed a gaping security hole that wasn’t fixed six months after he reported it to election authorities.
Denton County keeps Hart InterCivic as vendor, returns to paper ballots
After a disastrous November election, Denton County is planning a complete return to paper ballots. The move is in part a response to voter distrust of electronic voting machines.
Penn Wharton releases Study on the State of U.S. Voting Machines and Elections
As several news outlets have reported in the past eighteen months, there is an “impending crisis” in the nation’s voting machines.
Denton County, Texas calls for Investigation of Hart InterCivic
To all residents of Denton County: Your election last month was such a disaster that when we review what happened in total, it’s a wonder your county leaders haven’t demanded an immediate investigation by an outsider.
Dominion deletes mail-in votes remotely in NJ election
“Our problems with Dominion have become chronic and will not be tolerated. We are continuing to investigate the situation and will be holding Dominion fully accountable.”
Sequoia vote switch in NJ prompts investigation
A review of the ballot prior to the election didn’t catch that the names on the ballot had been swapped, meaning when a person voted for one of the Zirkles, the vote was actually counted toward the tally for the Henrys.
Dominion Acquires Sequoia Voting Systems
Sequoia Voting Systems was a California-based company that is one of the largest providers of electronic voting systems in the U.S., having offices in Oakland, Denver and New York City. Some of its major competitors were Premier Election Solutions (formerly Diebold Election Systems) and Election Systems & Software. At the time it had contracts for 300 jurisdictions in 16 states through its BPS, WinEDS, Edge, Edge2, Advantage, Insight, InsightPlus and 400C systems.
Dominion acquires Premier Election Solutions
“We are extremely pleased to conclude this transaction, which will restore much-needed competition to the American voting systems market and will allow Dominion to expand its capabilities and operational footprint to every corner of the United States,” said John Poulos, CEO of Dominion. The transaction was approved by the Department of Justice and nine state attorneys general.
Smartmatic machines tested in localities around the Philippines failed at a rate of almost 100% a Week before Election
Contrary to initial reports, votes were miscounted for both local and national candidates, in different ways is different localities. At first, Smartmatic technicians claimed that the problem was because the ballot paper used for the testing was thinner than the real paper to be used on election day. When this was disproven, the official explanation from Smartmatic was that the compact flash cards were improperly programmed.
Justice Department requires ES&S divestment of premier election solutions
The Department of Justice announced today that it will require Election Systems & Software (ES&S) to divest voting equipment systems assets it purchased in September 2009 from Premier Election Solutions Inc. in order to restore competition. Includes hardware, software and firmware used to record, tabulate, transmit or report votes, including the Assure 1.2 system, and a license to better serve disabled voters.
ES&S, once again the provider in Sarasota, now dominates the field
Two years after being shown the door for its role in an election that local officials would just as soon forget, voting machine maker ES&S is once again overseeing the system Sarasota County residents will use to cast their votes. ES&S’ purchase earlier this month of Premier Election Solutions means the company will now provide the voting machines, software and services to 68 percent of the precincts in the United States.
Hart InterCivic files lawsuit over sale of Diebold (Premier Election Solutions) to ES&S
The lawsuit alleges that a combined ES&S and Diebold would possess over 68% of the voting machine and election services market and that ES&S, post-merger, would have the power to raise price and reduce competition in the market. Hart’s complaint includes a litany of examples of ES&S and Diebold exerting power over local jurisdictions, particularly after a jurisdiction is “locked-in” to their touch screen systems.
ES&S acquires Premier Election Solutions (Formerly owned by Diebold)
Election Systems & Software (ES&S) acquired Premier Election Solutions on September 3, 2009. ES&S President and CEO Aldo Tesi said combining the two companies will result in better products and services for customers and voters. The sale did not affect the Brazilian division.
CIA agent claims the 2004 election and recount in Venezuela was rigged for Chavez using Smartmatic
The agent further stated that Chavez controlled all of the voting equipment before the election. Although not mentioned by the CIA agent expressly, this would have included Smartmatic’s voting machines. In addition to Venezuela, he suggested that similar schemes exist in Macedonia and Ukraine.
Despite claiming divestment of Sequoia, Smartmatic continues to raise questions
Efforts to date have not succeeded in determining the ultimate owners of Smartmatic or the extent to which Smartmatic and the Chávez government of Venezuela have influence over U.S. elections through Smartmatic’s control of the software that counts votes for Sequoia voting machines. Sequoia steadfastly maintains that the 2007 Sequoia management buy-out “completely eliminates Smartmatic’s ownership, control and operational rights of any kind in Sequoia”.
Smartmatic lies to Chicago Officials regarding ownership
The CEO and President of one of America’s largest voting machine companies, Sequoia Voting Systems, gave both deceptive, and carefully selective, answers in his reply to a letter sent earlier this year from two high-ranking officials in Chicago, according to documents recently obtained during an ongoing investigation.
Smartmatic Founding partner Jose Anzola Jaumotte dies in a plane crash
Also killed in the accident were the pilot, Mario Jose Donadi, a convicted drug-trafficker in both the United States and Venezuela; Smartmatic employee Eduardo Ramirez and two residents of the home that was struck by the falling aircraft at about 10 a.m. Monday.
Smartmatic continues to operate Sequoia, despite CFIUS
Smartmatic continues to own the software that counts the votes on Sequoia voting machines and licenses to Sequoia that software, which Smartmatic develops in Venezuela.
Hart InerCivic whistleblower alleges company lied to election officials
A former technician who worked for Hart InterCivic — a voting machine company based in Texas — has alleged that his company lied to election officials about the accuracy, testing, reliability and security of its voting machines. The whistleblower says the company did so because it was eager to obtain some of the approximately $4 billion in federal funds that Congress allocated to states in 2002 to purchase new voting equipment under the Help America Vote Act (aka HAVA).
CEO of Sequoia issues deceptive response to Burke, claiming no ties to Smartmatic
As a federal investigation by the Treasury Department’s CFIUS was closing in on the true provenance of Smartmatic’s shadowy ownership, and after a failed attempt to find an outside buyer for the company, Blaine and several other Sequoia and/or Smartmatic executives formed SVS Holdings, Inc., and proceeded to purchase Sequoia from the parent company.
Burke confirms Smartmatic sale of Sequoia a ‘sham’ and Venezuelan technicians are servicing US machines
In a letter to the Chicago Board of Elections, Chairman Langdon D. Neal, Alderman Burke is reported to have “expressed surprise” that Jack Blaine testified under oath in the 2006 Chicago hearings that “software components from the Sequoia system were developed in Venezuela [including the critical component of the Sequoia systems – the HAAT] and that ‘the Venezuelans have access to the Sequoia code.’”Burke reiterated his dismay that Jack Blaine furthermore admitted that he could not answer whether or not Hugo Chávez was a Smartmatic shareholder
CA Releases Source Code Review of Diebold, Hart Intercivic and Sequoia Voting Machines
The Diebold system still had many of the most serious security flaws that computer scientists had uncovered in the system years ago, despite Diebold’s claims that problems had been fixed. These include vulnerabilities that would allow an attacker to install malicious software to record votes incorrectly or miscount them or that would allow an attacker with access to only one machine and its memory card to launch a vote-stealing virus that could spread to every machine in a county.
Diebold changes name to Premier Election Solutions
In 2006, Diebold decided to remove its name from the front of the voting machines for strategic reasons. CEO Thomas Swidarski announced he would decide in the beginning of 2007 if Diebold stays in the election business.[4] In August 2007 the company changed its name to “Premier Election Solutions” (“PES”).
CA Released results of Investigation: All Three Systems can be compromised
The team found that it could compromise all three of the top voting systems used in the state made by Diebold Election Systems, Hart Intercivic, and Sequoia Voting Systems, with the caveat that many, but not all, of the attacks they were able to accomplish on the machines could be mitigated with proper physical security of the machines, security training of staff, and contingency planning. Detailed results here.
ES&S systems in Florida Missing 18,000 e-votes in close rase
Nearly 13 percent of voters in Sarasota County picked candidates in other races but did not choose a candidate in the House race. More than 35 callers to Common Cause’s voter hotline left messages Tuesday saying the e-voting machines appeared to leave off a vote for Jennings on their summary screens, said Ben Wilcox, executive director of Common Cause Florida. In neighboring Manatee County, just 2 percent of voters did not cast a ballot in the congressional race.
U.S. Investigates Smartmatic Voting Machines’ Venezuela Ties
The federal government is investigating the takeover last year of a leading American manufacturer of electronic voting systems by a small software company that has been linked to the leftist Venezuelan government of President Hugo Chávez.
Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney expresses concern over the sale of Sequoia to Smartmatic
It is undisputed that Smartmatic is foreign-owned and it has acquired Sequoia, one of the three major voting machine companies doing business in the U.S. According to a Sequoia press release in May 2006. Sequoia voting machines were used to record over 125 million votes during the 2004 Presidential election in the United States. As we confront another election, Americans deserve to know that the Administration has made sure that any foreign ownership of voting machines poses no national security threat.
Questions surround Venezuela and Smartmatic, Eyes US via subsidiary Sequoia
Smartmatic has claimed to be of U.S. origin, but its true owners — probably elite Venezuelans of several political strains — remain hidden behind a web of holding companies in the Netherlands and Barbados. The Smartmatic machines used in Venezuela are widely suspected of, though never proven conclusively to be, susceptible to fraud. The company is thought to be backing out of Venezuelan electoral events, focusing now on other parts of world, including the United States via its subsidiary, Sequoia.
Diebold and ES&S to count 80% of all votes in upcoming election
Diebold and ES&S, will count (using BOTH computerized ballot scanners and touchscreen machines) about 80% of all votes cast in the upcoming U.S. presidential election.
Diebold referred for civil and criminal charges
By an 8-0 vote, the state’s (California) Voting Systems and Procedures Panel recommended that Secretary of State Shelley cease the use of the machines, saying that Texas-based Diebold has performed poorly in California and its machines malfunctioned in the state’s March 2 primary election, turning away many voters in San Diego County. In addition to the ban, panel members recommended that a secretary of state’s office report released Wednesday, detailing alleged failings of Diebold in California, be forwarded to the state attorney general’s office to consider civil and criminal charges against the company.
Diebold employs 5 convicted felons as senior managers and developers to help write the central compiler computer code that counted 50% of the votes in 30 states
At least five convicted felons secured management positions at a manufacturer of electronic voting machines, according to critics demanding more stringent background checks for people responsible for voting machine software. Voter advocate Bev Harris alleged Tuesday that managers of a subsidiary of Diebold, one of the country’s largest voting equipment vendors, included a cocaine trafficker, a man who conducted fraudulent stock transactions and a programmer jailed for falsifying computer records.
Diebold admits to using insecure FTP server to update software remotely
Employees of Diebold Election Systems admitted that they had been using an insecure FTP server to exchange and update some part of Diebold’s software.
John Poulos starts Dominion Voting Systems
Dominion’s system mixes electronics and paper, combining an analog paper trail of each person’s vote with the advantages of quick, digital tallying. Its optical scanning technology is widely respected but American clients, at least post-Florida, looked on Dominion’s use of paper as quaint. “That was not seen as sexy,” Poulos says.
Tom Flocco claims Diebold machines compromised
A dishonest presidential election sets aside the future economic, social and military will of the American people. There is substantial evidence that electronic voting machine corporations and political forces in some states could turn aside the electoral wishes of the U.S. populace on November 2 by means of election fraud. “By entering a 2-digit code in a hidden location, a second set of votes is created; and this set of votes can be changed in a matter of seconds, so that it no longer matches the correct votes.”
Sequoia’s Regional Manager faces 49 years for bribes
Sequoia Pacific’s Regional Manager, Phil Foster, and their regional sales executive, Pasquale (Rocco) Ricci (also owner of New Jersey-based Independent Voting Machine Services), were indicted for paying out about $8 million in bribes to Louisiana Commissioner of Elections Jerry Fowler.
ES&S Admit Voting machines unreliable
Despite acknowledging “failure rates” ranging from 16 percent to 28 percent, election officials here express no concern for the integrity of the ballot in the age of voting machines.
ES&S is formed out of a merger of BRC and AIS
American Information Systems acquired the Election Services Division of Business Records Corporation and was reincorporated as Election Systems & Software, Inc. in December 1997. At the time, AIS had about 750 customers and BRC had around 1200, where each customer was typically a county election office. As a result of this merger, ES&S became the largest voting system vendor in the United States.
Sequoia buys BRC’s optical scan vote tabulation business
Sequoia Pacific Systems of Exeter, California, a division of St. Louis, Missouri-based Smurfit Packaging Corp., will buy Business Records’ optical scan vote tabulation business. Sequoia Pacific is a leading maker of direct recording electronic vote tabulation equipment with substantial experience in the elections business. Under the terms of the divestiture, Sequoia Pacific will immediately be able to compete for sales of such products.
Sequoia fraudulently inflates numbers
The Complaint alleges that Hudson, a former Sequoia salesman, together with three former officers of Sequoia, engaged in a fraudulent scheme to inflate the revenue and pre-tax income reported by Sequoia in its periodic and annual reports and financial statements that were publicly disseminated and filed with the Commission. Sequoia is a Nasdaq-listed company headquartered in Marlborough, Massachusetts, engaged in the design, manufacture and service of fault-tolerant computer systems.